For the first month, I didn't have automated emails. I didn't set up opt-ins until the end of the month and those were just simple lead magnets with no follow-up emails at the time.
On Etsy, my conversion rates were lower, but they were starting to rise when Etsy killed my account.
View attachment 47997
It took a while on Etsy to get the ads dialed in. For the first month or so I wasn't sure ads were worth it. Once I figured out which products were popular, then I adjusted my ads and the results started to improve.
Website conversions were always higher than Etsy. Over the lifetime they're at 15.8%.
View attachment 47998
A lot of my customers are repeat buyers, but recently I switched from Max Click Google Ads campaigns to Max Conversion campaigns and I'm seeing the number of first-time purchases increase.
I don't know how many of those people buy on their first visit, but my website doesn't have a cart. My product page button says "Order Now" and goes straight to checkout.
Currently, if someone joins my list they get 7 days of emails. I also send non-automated campaigns 4-5 days per week.
My product pages are built out like long-form direct-response sales pages with around 2,000 words of text, but only the first paragraph or two differs from one product to another. Everything else is just a drag-n-drop template from one product to the next.