- Joined
- Jan 17, 2023
- Messages
- 230
Rep Bank
$1,275
$1,275
User Power: 179%
[PROGRESS/LEARNING THREAD]
Tldr: SaaS entrepreneur who failed due to a small TAM and too little actual added value is changing direction.
I have been a member of this wonderful forum for just over a year now. During this time I have been able to learn from so many different people/entrepreneurs - the added value generated as a result is priceless! (Thanks for that guys (too many ppl to @)
I think it's time to give something back too. Spoiler: Unfortunately not a typical success story, but things that I learned in the course of my execution. Things that I would do differently in retrospect and will do differently(!).
My background in brief: Graduate > Software Dev > Freelance Consultant (Technical SEO) > Fastlane entrepreneur (current, kind of… :X)
Business plan in brief: Create added value through software (time savings and/or more sales) + Business Model: SaaS
Business plan in detail (but still short, because I don't have one): I focused heavily on automating various activities in the field of performance marketing and e-commerce. My focus was also on providing market research data to give the same target group a competitive advantage. These software solutions were implemented exclusively in the form of Chrome extensions, as the nature of this type of software is ideal for these activities. I also found - after initial difficulties - a way to gain complete control over this type of software, which in turn fulfills the control aspect. I currently have 6 micro SaaS solutions available for the market/live for exactly this target group and the respective areas of application.
Now to the core of this thread: What has worked well so far and what has worked less well/badly?
What worked well:
These are average industry values. 20 extensions are not exactly a small number. Nor are 5000 installs per extension. Even if I were to achieve these values, which is more towards unrealistic, I would at best achieve a slightly above-average income compared to my country.
If there is one or, in the best case, several competitors, the probability is high that there is a correspondingly high need for this solution.
If not, then there may still be a correspondingly high need, or it is a pure vitamin product that is nice to have, but nobody would pay for it.
The final/current problem:
The TAM of the target group would in principle be large enough (e-commerce businesses & performance marketers), but I serve a much smaller sub-niche with my solutions. Example: Only Amazon FBA sellers who operate in Europe. This, combined with too little actual added value, which I also fairly promote as perceived value, is currently breaking my neck. And I have enough users who support this problem.
I don't blame anyone but myself, but I would be lying if I said that this situation doesn't piss me off. It sucks, but I think I pulled the handbrake early enough.
What have I learned from this?
Next steps:
I'm sticking with the same niche, as there are really a lot of problems in it and I have a lot of insights into it. However…
A big thank you to so many members of this forum who - even if they don't know it directly - have helped me a lot over the past year with their views/opinions/realities.
I'm very positive about what lies ahead of me, even if I'm back at position 0. However, this time not in the sense of knowledge, but much more in the sense of getting started (again).
Tldr: SaaS entrepreneur who failed due to a small TAM and too little actual added value is changing direction.
I have been a member of this wonderful forum for just over a year now. During this time I have been able to learn from so many different people/entrepreneurs - the added value generated as a result is priceless! (Thanks for that guys (too many ppl to @)
I think it's time to give something back too. Spoiler: Unfortunately not a typical success story, but things that I learned in the course of my execution. Things that I would do differently in retrospect and will do differently(!).
My background in brief: Graduate > Software Dev > Freelance Consultant (Technical SEO) > Fastlane entrepreneur (current, kind of… :X)
Business plan in brief: Create added value through software (time savings and/or more sales) + Business Model: SaaS
Business plan in detail (but still short, because I don't have one): I focused heavily on automating various activities in the field of performance marketing and e-commerce. My focus was also on providing market research data to give the same target group a competitive advantage. These software solutions were implemented exclusively in the form of Chrome extensions, as the nature of this type of software is ideal for these activities. I also found - after initial difficulties - a way to gain complete control over this type of software, which in turn fulfills the control aspect. I currently have 6 micro SaaS solutions available for the market/live for exactly this target group and the respective areas of application.
Now to the core of this thread: What has worked well so far and what has worked less well/badly?
What worked well:
- I have learned more in the last 12 months than in 5 years of studying business at university.
- I have not only managed to generate one customer, but many paying customers who saw added value in my products. So I have successfully established the basic skills for creating a specialized unit and creating a business system.
- I felt like I was able to eliminate 80% of my initial worries (before I threw myself into this business model and creating added value through software) because they were only in my head and were resolved during the execution. I feel a lot more confident in some areas (not all of them - lol) than before.
- I feel much more mature, even though I failed at the end of the day. The learnings I had in the last year, at 29, were much greater than the learnings I had in my entire 20s in terms of actual knowledge gain and REAL self-improvement - more on that now...
- Despite the knowledge from the MJ trilogy and the belief that I understood and internalized the concepts contained therein, I still reached for the hot stove like a young child, not just once, but many times.
- My TAM is way too small
- I thought I had found a fastlane through II (Intentional Iteration) - similar to a franchising company - using a large number of different SaaS products, as I have discovered a lot of problems in recent years that have either not been solved or have been solved very poorly. But: Even 6 Micro SaaS with several thousand free users is an absolute pain to maintain and support; apart from that, I have no processes in place, which I can replicate as all of the products aren't identical/similiar. It's not like McDonalds, where the products and processes are the same. Each of my products is different. Systematization is therefore only partially possible.
- The actual added value created per product does not justify "higher" prices. In other words: If I sell a SaaS product between $2-5/month - I cannot artificially charge more because in my opinion it does not justify the actual added value delivered to my customer - the number of free users required with a freemium model would be so high that I would probably never reach this goal (due to the TAM).
These are average industry values. 20 extensions are not exactly a small number. Nor are 5000 installs per extension. Even if I were to achieve these values, which is more towards unrealistic, I would at best achieve a slightly above-average income compared to my country.
- No pre-validation (hard-proof) of my ideas
If there is one or, in the best case, several competitors, the probability is high that there is a correspondingly high need for this solution.
If not, then there may still be a correspondingly high need, or it is a pure vitamin product that is nice to have, but nobody would pay for it.
The final/current problem:
The TAM of the target group would in principle be large enough (e-commerce businesses & performance marketers), but I serve a much smaller sub-niche with my solutions. Example: Only Amazon FBA sellers who operate in Europe. This, combined with too little actual added value, which I also fairly promote as perceived value, is currently breaking my neck. And I have enough users who support this problem.
I don't blame anyone but myself, but I would be lying if I said that this situation doesn't piss me off. It sucks, but I think I pulled the handbrake early enough.
What have I learned from this?
- Choose a TAM that is large enough to help as many people as possible
- Solve problems that have already been validated (existing, successful software products with SaaS business model)
- Change in my basic motivation/purpose to go fastlane
Next steps:
I'm sticking with the same niche, as there are really a lot of problems in it and I have a lot of insights into it. However…
- Reverse-engineer an already validated idea that is also economically viable (more than $20/user/year and/or where the TAM is large enough)
- Identify gaps in this idea (gaps where I can skew value)
- Create an MVP based on it (with the appropriate skews)
- Set up a business system and promote the MVP
A big thank you to so many members of this forum who - even if they don't know it directly - have helped me a lot over the past year with their views/opinions/realities.
I'm very positive about what lies ahead of me, even if I'm back at position 0. However, this time not in the sense of knowledge, but much more in the sense of getting started (again).
Dislike ads? Become a Fastlane member:
Subscribe today and surround yourself with winners and millionaire mentors, not those broke friends who only want to drink beer and play video games. :-)
Last edited:
Membership Required: Upgrade to Expose Nearly 1,000,000 Posts
Ready to Unleash the Millionaire Entrepreneur in You?
Become a member of the Fastlane Forum, the private community founded by best-selling author and multi-millionaire entrepreneur MJ DeMarco. Since 2007, MJ DeMarco has poured his heart and soul into the Fastlane Forum, helping entrepreneurs reclaim their time, win their financial freedom, and live their best life.
With more than 39,000 posts packed with insights, strategies, and advice, you’re not just a member—you’re stepping into MJ’s inner-circle, a place where you’ll never be left alone.
Become a member and gain immediate access to...
- Active Community: Ever join a community only to find it DEAD? Not at Fastlane! As you can see from our home page, life-changing content is posted dozens of times daily.
- Exclusive Insights: Direct access to MJ DeMarco’s daily contributions and wisdom.
- Powerful Networking Opportunities: Connect with a diverse group of successful entrepreneurs who can offer mentorship, collaboration, and opportunities.
- Proven Strategies: Learn from the best in the business, with actionable advice and strategies that can accelerate your success.
"You are the average of the five people you surround yourself with the most..."
Who are you surrounding yourself with? Surround yourself with millionaire success. Join Fastlane today!
Join Today