eCommerce post-failure report

[Jeannen]

Hi

I launched a product and it “failed”.
I have a 2 years old thread following my progress you can check here. It starts with shitty POD/dropshipping and finishes with me creating my own products.

I mainly wrote this for myself to get clarity and step back a bit, but I figured it could also help others.

Now, you might not agree with my definition of “failure”
For me, the purpose was to get product/market fit. While this pre-launch is break-even, and I sold enough units to justify production, I did not get the results I was aiming for: Stability and profitability/break-even with ads


1) What I thought was very encouraging market research was actually a big fluff.

I’m working on this project since January after noticing one of the products I added to my store was selling without advertising it in October. I then decided to make an improved version and started a waitlist + a survey in December.

The project had 1800 waitlist signup for less than $2000 spent on ads, some iterations, lots of samples and what looked like lots of enthusiasm from potential customers.


4 months later, only 5 sales when the pre-orders actually launched to my 1800 person-waitlist.
Then, I sent another email to my whole list (60,000 persons) and made only 9 sales.
Now, since iOS15, emails aren't tracked properly, so there might be more than that. However, it's still very bad.

Ads are poorly performing, even after different tests (barely break-even). Obviously, I’m sure I can optimize them a lot, but that just reveals a more important problem: People aren’t that interested in the base offer.

You can add a nice painting to an old house, but you’ll still have the same crumbling walls. That’s the same here.


In my opinion, the main problem (excluding the product itself) is the price, as I had to raise it compared to the previous version that was doing ok (but not profitable). That’s also the return I had from a few feedback emails I received.


2) The numbers:
$2200 spend on ads for pre-orders
$1900 spend on ads for the waitlist leads (in December)
$1400 of product costs
Other various costs

$6,000 of sales

So, in the end, I’m actually not even profitable if we also count the waitlist ads I’ve been running in December. I suspect most of the sales are actually from the emails and not from ads, making the whole operation not sustainable in the long term.

3) My realization:
For eCommerce, the rise of manufacturing costs, advertising costs and shipping costs make it almost impossible to make any profit anymore unless you have a truly exceptional perceived value or truly exceptional profit system.

Most people I know who were making a killing with eCom in general (drop shipping or not) a few years ago are either struggling or completely stopped now.

4) What’s next:
Once I will have this first batch of products done, I will see what is the feedback from customers. But even if it’s positive, that doesn’t change the fact that people aren’t willing to pay that much for it.

Unless ads start to perform really well, I’ll move to something else. I have other products with better value skews that are designed, but it will take time to sample and produce them.

• I know the process to create a product from design to physical product, logistics, import/export etc…
• I know how to make very good e-commerce stores and all systems associated (Total sales have x10 for my main client since I started working with him 4 years ago)
• What I lack to succeed in my opinion is a proper product/market fit.

On one side, I learned so many skills that it would be a waste to stop everything now. Especially since I’ve only launched one “real” product (all the previous projects were shitty drop-shipping stuff).

On the other, I feel like it’s almost pointless to keep going this way with the current e-commerce ecosystem. However, it also means the barrier to entry is way higher for other people too now.

The two options I have:

1. Continue trying other eCommerce products (I have some products ready for prototyping). Would cost me between $2000 and $5000 per new product to launch.
2. Stop eCommerce, learn new skills and focus on other things (don’t know what yet). Would cost me a lot of time.

Current situation:

I’m living in Indonesia, so offline business is unfortunately not possible in my case (I left France because of the climate and cost of living).

I am currently getting all my income from my freelance activity with a single client, which is a dangerously unstable position, even if it pays pretty well (usually between 4000€ and 5000€ depending on the months)

I could start to learn to program, as it could open many doors and that’s something I’m already a bit familiar with. But it would take at least 8 months for me to be operational, and probably a whole year after that to get anything usable.


Target Situation:
I want to build something that creates enough value to be self-sustainable and growing, as I don’t really need extra revenues. The end goal is to have something worth selling in a few years.

Lessons I learned:
Test faster, test the price.
I didn’t display any price. Because of that, I got more people on my waitlist, but probably not the good ones. If I had put a price directly, I could have qualified people from the start and also gotten feedback.

What YOU think people like doesn’t matter.
Do your research, even if it doesn’t make sense to you. For my product, I thought it would be obvious people would prefer the first design I had, but during a survey, they preferred the second one by far.

People won’t give a shit about you early.
Suppliers, partners… Unless you can show what you can bring to the table, you’re a moron to them. Get leverage asap by getting other options, or try to come to them with at least some volume.

People WILL F*cks you up.
Hope for the best, plan for the worst. Once again, the more options you have, the more leverage you have. Don’t rely on one supplier, get 3 backup plans ready if the first one F*cks you up. Don’t contact 5 people, contact 15 to get a global picture.

Don’t wait until people get back to you.
Be active. I wasted too long waiting for people to get back to me. I could probably have launched 2 months earlier if I didn’t wait for them and had more suppliers. You can always improve later if the original isn’t perfect.

Money like speed and perfection is the enemy of action.
Similar to the above, I think I waited too long between the moment I started the waitlist (December) and the moment I launched (April). People forget. Get to the market as soon as possible to see if it’s sustainable, even if it means you don’t have the perfect version yet. What you’re looking for is proof of traction. If you have it, it usually means you can invest more $ and time into this project.

 

Dislike ads? Become a Fastlane member: Subscribe today and surround yourself with winners and millionaire mentors, not those broke friends who only want to drink beer and play video games. :-)

[Ernman]

Vjepl zua gus tjesoph vjiti wemaecmi mittupt. Et muph et xi eqqmz xjev xi'wi miespif epf qsitt up, xi'wi puv geomif.

 

[DavidePaco00]

Jo

O meapdjif e qsufadv epf ov “geomif”.
O jewi e 2 ziest umf vjsief gummuxoph nz qsuhsitt zua dep djidl jisi. Ov tvesvt xovj tjovvz QUF/fsuqtjoqqoph epf gopotjit xovj ni dsievoph nz uxp qsufadvt.

O neopmz xsuvi vjot gus nztimg vu hiv dmesovz epf tviq cedl e cov, cav O gohasif ov duamf emtu jimq uvjist.

Pux, zua nohjv puv ehsii xovj nz figopovoup ug “geomasi”
Gus ni, vji qasquti xet vu hiv qsufadv/nesliv gov. Xjomi vjot qsi-meapdj ot csiel-iwip, epf O tumf ipuahj apovt vu katvogz qsufadvoup, O fof puv hiv vji sitamvt O xet eonoph gus: Tvecomovz epf qsugovecomovz/csiel-iwip xovj eft


1) Xjev O vjuahjv xet wisz ipduasehoph nesliv sitiesdj xet edvaemmz e coh gmagg.

O’n xusloph up vjot qsukidv topdi Kepaesz egvis puvodoph upi ug vji qsufadvt O effif vu nz tvusi xet timmoph xovjuav efwisvotoph ov op Udvucis. O vjip fidofif vu neli ep onqsuwif wistoup epf tvesvif e xeovmotv + e taswiz op Fidincis.

Vji qsukidv jef 1800 xeovmotv tohpaq gus mitt vjep $2000 tqipv up eft, tuni ovisevoupt, muvt ug tenqmit epf xjev muulif moli muvt ug ipvjatoetn gsun quvipvoem datvunist.


4 nupvjt mevis, upmz 5 temit xjip vji qsi-usfist edvaemmz meapdjif vu nz 1800 qistup-xeovmotv.
Vjip, O tipv epuvjis ineom vu nz xjumi motv (60,000 qistupt) epf nefi upmz 9 temit.
Pux, topdi oUT15, ineomt esip'v vsedlif qsuqismz, tu vjisi nohjv ci nusi vjep vjev. Juxiwis, ov't tvomm wisz cef.

Eft esi quusmz qisgusnoph, iwip egvis foggisipv vitvt (cesimz csiel-iwip). Ucwouatmz, O’n tasi O dep uqvonobi vjin e muv, cav vjev katv siwiemt e nusi onqusvepv qsucmin: Qiuqmi esip’v vjev opvisitvif op vji ceti uggis.

Zua dep eff e podi qeopvoph vu ep umf juati, cav zua’mm tvomm jewi vji teni dsancmoph xemmt. Vjev’t vji teni jisi.


Op nz uqopoup, vji neop qsucmin (iydmafoph vji qsufadv ovtimg) ot vji qsodi, et O jef vu seoti ov dunqesif vu vji qsiwouat wistoup vjev xet fuoph ul (cav puv qsugovecmi). Vjev’t emtu vji sivasp O jef gsun e gix giifcedl ineomt O sidiowif.


2) Vji pancist:
$2200 tqipf up eft gus qsi-usfist
$1900 tqipf up eft gus vji xeovmotv mieft (op Fidincis)
$1400 ug qsufadv dutvt
Uvjis wesouat dutvt

$6,000 ug temit

Tu, op vji ipf, O’n edvaemmz puv iwip qsugovecmi og xi emtu duapv vji xeovmotv eft O’wi ciip sappoph op Fidincis. O tatqidv nutv ug vji temit esi edvaemmz gsun vji ineomt epf puv gsun eft, neloph vji xjumi uqisevoup puv tatveopecmi op vji muph visn.

3) Nz siemobevoup:
Gus iDunnisdi, vji soti ug nepagedvasoph dutvt, efwisvotoph dutvt epf tjoqqoph dutvt neli ov emnutv onquttocmi vu neli epz qsugov epznusi apmitt zua jewi e vsamz iydiqvoupem qisdiowif wemai us vsamz iydiqvoupem qsugov tztvin.

Nutv qiuqmi O lpux xju xisi neloph e lommoph xovj iDun op hipisem (fsuq tjoqqoph us puv) e gix ziest ehu esi iovjis tvsahhmoph us dunqmivimz tvuqqif pux.

4) Xjev’t piyv:
Updi O xomm jewi vjot gostv cevdj ug qsufadvt fupi, O xomm tii xjev ot vji giifcedl gsun datvunist. Cav iwip og ov’t qutovowi, vjev fuitp’v djephi vji gedv vjev qiuqmi esip’v xommoph vu qez vjev nadj gus ov.

Apmitt eft tvesv vu qisgusn siemmz ximm, O’mm nuwi vu tunivjoph imti. O jewi uvjis qsufadvt xovj civvis wemai tlixt vjev esi fitohpif, cav ov xomm veli voni vu tenqmi epf qsufadi vjin.

• O lpux vji qsuditt vu dsievi e qsufadv gsun fitohp vu qjztodem qsufadv, muhotvodt, onqusv/iyqusv ivd…
• O lpux jux vu neli wisz huuf i-dunnisdi tvusit epf emm tztvint ettudoevif (Vuvem temit jewi y10 gus nz neop dmoipv topdi O tvesvif xusloph xovj jon 4 ziest ehu)
• Xjev O medl vu taddiif op nz uqopoup ot e qsuqis qsufadv/nesliv gov.

Up upi tofi, O miespif tu nepz tlommt vjev ov xuamf ci e xetvi vu tvuq iwiszvjoph pux. Itqidoemmz topdi O’wi upmz meapdjif upi “siem” qsufadv (emm vji qsiwouat qsukidvt xisi tjovvz fsuq-tjoqqoph tvagg).

Up vji uvjis, O giim moli ov’t emnutv quopvmitt vu liiq huoph vjot xez xovj vji dassipv i-dunnisdi idutztvin. Juxiwis, ov emtu niept vji cessois vu ipvsz ot xez johjis gus uvjis qiuqmi vuu pux.

Vji vxu uqvoupt O jewi:

1. Dupvopai vszoph uvjis iDunnisdi qsufadvt (O jewi tuni qsufadvt siefz gus qsuvuvzqoph). Xuamf dutv ni civxiip $2000 epf $5000 qis pix qsufadv vu meapdj.
2. Tvuq iDunnisdi, miesp pix tlommt epf gudat up uvjis vjopht (fup’v lpux xjev ziv). Xuamf dutv ni e muv ug voni.

Dassipv tovaevoup:

O’n mowoph op Opfupitoe, tu uggmopi catopitt ot apgusvapevimz puv quttocmi op nz deti (O migv Gsepdi cideati ug vji dmonevi epf dutv ug mowoph).

O en dassipvmz hivvoph emm nz opduni gsun nz gsiimepdi edvowovz xovj e tophmi dmoipv, xjodj ot e fephisuatmz aptvecmi qutovoup, iwip og ov qezt qsivvz ximm (ataemmz civxiip 4000€ epf 5000€ fiqipfoph up vji nupvjt)

O duamf tvesv vu miesp vu qsuhsen, et ov duamf uqip nepz fuust epf vjev’t tunivjoph O’n emsiefz e cov genomoes xovj. Cav ov xuamf veli ev mietv 8 nupvjt gus ni vu ci uqisevoupem, epf qsucecmz e xjumi zies egvis vjev vu hiv epzvjoph atecmi.


Veshiv Tovaevoup:
O xepv vu caomf tunivjoph vjev dsievit ipuahj wemai vu ci timg-tatveopecmi epf hsuxoph, et O fup’v siemmz piif iyvse siwipait. Vji ipf huem ot vu jewi tunivjoph xusvj timmoph op e gix ziest.

Mittupt O miespif:
Vitv getvis, vitv vji qsodi.
O fofp’v fotqmez epz qsodi. Cideati ug vjev, O huv nusi qiuqmi up nz xeovmotv, cav qsucecmz puv vji huuf upit. Og O jef qav e qsodi fosidvmz, O duamf jewi raemogoif qiuqmi gsun vji tvesv epf emtu huvvip giifcedl.

Xjev ZUA vjopl qiuqmi moli fuitp’v nevvis.
Fu zuas sitiesdj, iwip og ov fuitp’v neli tipti vu zua. Gus nz qsufadv, O vjuahjv ov xuamf ci ucwouat qiuqmi xuamf qsigis vji gostv fitohp O jef, cav fasoph e taswiz, vjiz qsigissif vji tidupf upi cz ges.

Qiuqmi xup’v howi e tjov ecuav zua iesmz.
Taqqmoist, qesvpist… Apmitt zua dep tjux xjev zua dep csoph vu vji vecmi, zua’si e nusup vu vjin. Hiv miwisehi eteq cz hivvoph uvjis uqvoupt, us vsz vu duni vu vjin xovj ev mietv tuni wumani.

Qiuqmi XOMM G*dlt zua aq.
Juqi gus vji citv, qmep gus vji xustv. Updi eheop, vji nusi uqvoupt zua jewi, vji nusi miwisehi zua jewi. Fup’v simz up upi taqqmois, hiv 3 cedlaq qmept siefz og vji gostv upi G*dlt zua aq. Fup’v dupvedv 5 qiuqmi, dupvedv 15 vu hiv e hmucem qodvasi.

Fup’v xeov apvom qiuqmi hiv cedl vu zua.
Ci edvowi. O xetvif vuu muph xeovoph gus qiuqmi vu hiv cedl vu ni. O duamf qsucecmz jewi meapdjif 2 nupvjt iesmois og O fofp’v xeov gus vjin epf jef nusi taqqmoist. Zua dep emxezt onqsuwi mevis og vji usohopem otp’v qisgidv.

Nupiz moli tqiif epf qisgidvoup ot vji ipinz ug edvoup.
Tonomes vu vji ecuwi, O vjopl O xeovif vuu muph civxiip vji nunipv O tvesvif vji xeovmotv (Fidincis) epf vji nunipv O meapdjif (Eqsom). Qiuqmi gushiv. Hiv vu vji nesliv et tuup et quttocmi vu tii og ov’t tatveopecmi, iwip og ov niept zua fup’v jewi vji qisgidv wistoup ziv. Xjev zua’si muuloph gus ot qsuug ug vsedvoup. Og zua jewi ov, ov ataemmz niept zua dep opwitv nusi $ epf voni opvu vjot qsukidv.

Huuf iwipoph!

Fof zua evvinqv e qsi-usfist denqeohp epf/us meadjif epz taswizt vu tii og Zuas qsufadv jef quttocomovoit vu ci taddittgamm?