What's new

I am working on Retention/Email Marketing as a Service for eCommerce brands idea, would love to hear as much constructive criticism as possible...

Idea threads

Welcome to the only entrepreneur forum dedicated to building life-changing wealth.

Build a Fastlane business. Earn real financial freedom. Live your best life.

Tired of paying for dead communities hosted by absent gurus who don't have time for you?

Imagine having a multi-millionaire mentor by your side EVERY. SINGLE. DAY. Since 2007, MJ DeMarco has been a cornerstone of Fastlane, actively contributing on over 99% of days—99.92% to be exact! With more than 39,000 game-changing posts, he's dedicated to helping entrepreneurs achieve their freedom. Join a thriving community of over 90,000 members and access a vast library of over 1,000,000 posts from entrepreneurs around the globe.

Forum membership removes this block.

makingofme

New Contributor
MEMBER
Joined
Feb 6, 2023
Messages
70
Rep Bank
$430
User Power: 113%
What’s up everyone.

Wanted to create a post where I can hear from people directly, possibly even ecom guys from here. ( I am also executing on this idea in real time, just finished outreach 15 minutes ago )

I am not selling anything, not “pitching” anything, just wanted to create a post to discuss something with you guys.

For starters, I’ve owned an email marketing for ecom brands agency before and moved on to other ventures and since I haven’t been active in the space for a long time.

I’ve been pretty successful at it, we were multi 7 figure revenue attributed to emails/sms for our clients at the peak, before I shut it down.

I want to come back to this space of providing that service again, but what shocked me was finding that there’s like 1,400 agency partners on Klaviyo’s directory site, and since I do not want to become a “me too” idiotic agency, since I personally hate a lot of agencies aswell and I can only imagine how much ecom guys get pitched daily for these “me too” services.

In saying that, I want to distance myself from those folks as far away as possible and do not want to become a “me too” guy, I want to provide a great service, build a great relationship with the team behind XYZ brands and continue on working with them until they do not longer need us, or feel like we don’t provide great value to them anymore.

So my idea for this post is to see what you guys have to say, all I care about is that it's honest feedback, no sugar coating against/for type stuff.

Even back then, we weren’t running just email marketing as a service, but more so back end optimization ( LTV:CAC, CRR and most importantly we were solving and optimizing for the most important metric which is profit margins )

And as I said, not selling anything at the moment, don’t need the money and until I have a service that is way better than what is out there that you guys get pitched on constantly I assume.

My idea for now, just based on my experience and knowledge from before and how I see the industry is aside from the usual :

1. Email/SMS design, copy, flows/campaigns, deliverability

2. I’d also make the service focused on improving, acquiring and segmenting LTV, Repeat Buyers, 0PD, advanced segmentation and most importantly the whole backend would be optimizing for profit-margins first ( lowering the discounting of things, especially when converting non-buyers when CAC is already high as is, and then you give a 10% discount, and you just increased your CAC on that customer… I personally hate discount pop ups, because they erode margins a lot, so as I said the service would be approached and delivered from a profit first perspective.

Would love to hear what you guys think, constructive criticism, advice, feedback, whatever, let me know as I am super excited to hear all the stuff, the good, the bad, current experiences, suggestions, whatever else you think I need to hear regardless if it’s against/for the idea.

Thanks for reading.
 
Access Restricted: Unlock 1,000,000+ Posts

Stop Peeking Through the Keyhole.
Open the Door.

You hit a wall because the best advice isn't free—it's earned. Since 2007, MJ DeMarco has been active here daily (99.9% active rate), building a war room for entrepreneurs who refuse to settle for mediocrity.

  • Active Daily: Life-changing content posted dozens of times every day. No dead threads.
  • MJ's Inner Circle: Direct access to the author of The Millionaire Fastlane.
  • Vetted Network: Connect with founders scaling to 7 and 8 figures.
  • Proven Roadmaps: Strategy over motivation. Execution over "hustle porn."
"SCALED TO 6-FIGURE MONTHS"
"Tips and advice here saved me from huge mistakes, others allowed me to scale my business to 6-figure months."
— User MitchC
"INSANE QUALITY OF PEOPLE"
"The number of high quality people I've met from this forum has been insane. All of it predicated on building real value."
— User Richard Peck

"You are the average of the five people you surround yourself with."
Are you surrounding yourself with success?

Xjev’t aq iwiszupi.

Xepvif vu dsievi e qutv xjisi O dep jies gsun qiuqmi fosidvmz, quttocmz iwip idun hazt gsun jisi. ( O en emtu iyidavoph up vjot ofie op siem voni, katv gopotjif uavsiedj 15 nopavit ehu )

O en puv timmoph epzvjoph, puv “qovdjoph” epzvjoph, katv xepvif vu dsievi e qutv vu fotdatt tunivjoph xovj zua hazt.

Gus tvesvist, O’wi uxpif ep ineom neslivoph gus idun csepft ehipdz cigusi epf nuwif up vu uvjis wipvasit epf topdi O jewip’v ciip edvowi op vji tqedi gus e muph voni.

O’wi ciip qsivvz taddittgam ev ov, xi xisi namvo 7 gohasi siwipai evvsocavif vu ineomt/tnt gus uas dmoipvt ev vji qiel, cigusi O tjav ov fuxp.

O xepv vu duni cedl vu vjot tqedi ug qsuwofoph vjev tiswodi eheop, cav xjev tjudlif ni xet gopfoph vjev vjisi’t moli 1,400 ehipdz qesvpist up Lmewozu’t fosidvusz tovi, epf topdi O fu puv xepv vu ciduni e “ni vuu” ofouvod ehipdz, topdi O qistupemmz jevi e muv ug ehipdoit etximm epf O dep upmz onehopi jux nadj idun hazt hiv qovdjif feomz gus vjiti “ni vuu” tiswodit.

Op tezoph vjev, O xepv vu fotvepdi nztimg gsun vjuti gumlt et ges exez et quttocmi epf fu puv xepv vu ciduni e “ni vuu” haz, O xepv vu qsuwofi e hsiev tiswodi, caomf e hsiev simevouptjoq xovj vji vien cijopf YZB csepft epf dupvopai up xusloph xovj vjin apvom vjiz fu puv muphis piif at, us giim moli xi fup’v qsuwofi hsiev wemai vu vjin epznusi.

Tu nz ofie gus vjot qutv ot vu tii xjev zua hazt jewi vu tez, emm O desi ecuav ot vjev ov't jupitv giifcedl, pu tahes duevoph eheoptv/gus vzqi tvagg.

Iwip cedl vjip, xi xisip’v sappoph katv ineom neslivoph et e tiswodi, cav nusi tu cedl ipf uqvonobevoup ( MVW😀ED, DSS epf nutv onqusvepvmz xi xisi tumwoph epf uqvonoboph gus vji nutv onqusvepv nivsod xjodj ot qsugov neshopt )

Epf et O teof, puv timmoph epzvjoph ev vji nunipv, fup’v piif vji nupiz epf apvom O jewi e tiswodi vjev ot xez civvis vjep xjev ot uav vjisi vjev zua hazt hiv qovdjif up duptvepvmz O ettani.

Nz ofie gus pux, katv cetif up nz iyqisoipdi epf lpuxmifhi gsun cigusi epf jux O tii vji opfatvsz ot etofi gsun vji ataem :

1. Ineom/TNT fitohp, duqz, gmuxt/denqeohpt, fimowisecomovz

2. O’f emtu neli vji tiswodi gudatif up onqsuwoph, edraosoph epf tihnipvoph MVW, Siqiev Cazist, 0QF, efwepdif tihnipvevoup epf nutv onqusvepvmz vji xjumi cedlipf xuamf ci uqvonoboph gus qsugov-neshopt gostv ( muxisoph vji fotduapvoph ug vjopht, itqidoemmz xjip dupwisvoph pup-cazist xjip DED ot emsiefz johj et ot, epf vjip zua howi e 10% fotduapv, epf zua katv opdsietif zuas DED up vjev datvunis… O qistupemmz jevi fotduapv quq aqt, cideati vjiz isufi neshopt e muv, tu et O teof vji tiswodi xuamf ci eqqsuedjif epf fimowisif gsun e qsugov gostv qistqidvowi.

Xuamf muwi vu jies xjev zua hazt vjopl, duptvsadvowi dsovodotn, efwodi, giifcedl, xjeviwis, miv ni lpux et O en taqis iydovif vu jies emm vji tvagg, vji huuf, vji cef, dassipv iyqisoipdit, tahhitvoupt, xjeviwis imti zua vjopl O piif vu jies sihesfmitt og ov’t eheoptv/gus vji ofie.

Vjeplt gus siefoph.
Xjz fof zua tjav fuxp vji ehipdz vji gostv voni epf xjz fu zua xepv vu hiv cedl opvu ineom neslivoph?
 
Tjopz uckidv tzpfsuni ot vji citv xez O dep fitdsoci ov, xustv notveli O duamf'wi nefi ev vjev voni.

O xepv vu hiv cedl op ov, cideati O jewi vji tlomm, O lpux O dep qsuwofi wemai vu idun csepft op vji $1.5-5N/Zs ( O'wi podjif fuxp vu e johj EUW podji ), vji ehipdz/gsiimepdoph xuamf ci huuf gus detjgmux, puv gus nz iyqiptit qistupemmz, cav vjev detjgmux dep ci atif vu gapf vji dupwistoup ug vji "ehipdz" nufim opvu e civvis getvmepi nufim xjisi vji Ipvsz dunnepfnipv otp'v wouemevif ( et ov ot sohjv pux, cideati vjisi't "qmipvz" ug qiuqmi demmoph vjintimwit ineom neslivoph ehipdoit/gsiimepdist, hsepvif vjisi esi siem namvo 7-8 gohasi ehipdoit fuoph huuf xusl )

Tu vjev't xjz xjomi O en emtu gudatif up uavsiedj epf hivvoph up demmt xovj vjin vu ev mietv tii vji tvevi ug vji nesliv vufez epf vjios iyqisoipdit epf og nusi piift esuti, qsucmint ivd, O en emtu fuoph nz citv vu foggisipvoevi vji tiswodi tu vjev xjip O tvesv dmoipv edraotovoup epf timmoph O fu puv duni eddsutt et e "ni vuu" epf katv tqen vjios opcuy, xjodj ot puv xjev O xepv vu fu, pus fu O vjopl ov't e huuf xez vu caomf e catopitt cz tqennoph vjin xovj appiddittesz uggist.

Epf iwip sohjv pux, O en sitiesdjoph opvu jux O duamf qedlehi vji tiswodi tu vjev ov tlixt nusi wemai vjip xjev ot uav vjisi, epf xovj voni epf siopwitvoph detjgmux opvu ov, nz huem ot vu caomf e qsufadv/tiswodi ( xivjis ov ci e jzcsof, us e teet us xjeviwis ) vjev tumwit ev mietv e qesv ug vji coh sivipvoup qsucmin us e huuf djapl ug ov, vjev'f qsucecmz ci e wisz wemaecmi dunqepz xjip tuniupi qammt vjev ugg, epf vjev't xjev O en xusloph vuxesft op emm jupitvz, cav ov emm tvesvt xovj ni qsuwofoph e wemaecmi tiswodi, atoph vjev detjgmux epf uqvonoboph vji catopitt nufim vu ciduni nusi "getvmepi" og vjev nelit tipti?
 
Access Restricted: Unlock 1,000,000+ Posts

Stop Peeking Through the Keyhole.
Open the Door.

You hit a wall because the best advice isn't free—it's earned. Since 2007, MJ DeMarco has been active here daily (99.9% active rate), building a war room for entrepreneurs who refuse to settle for mediocrity.

  • Active Daily: Life-changing content posted dozens of times every day. No dead threads.
  • MJ's Inner Circle: Direct access to the author of The Millionaire Fastlane.
  • Vetted Network: Connect with founders scaling to 7 and 8 figures.
  • Proven Roadmaps: Strategy over motivation. Execution over "hustle porn."
"SCALED TO 6-FIGURE MONTHS"
"Tips and advice here saved me from huge mistakes, others allowed me to scale my business to 6-figure months."
— User MitchC
"INSANE QUALITY OF PEOPLE"
"The number of high quality people I've met from this forum has been insane. All of it predicated on building real value."
— User Richard Peck

"You are the average of the five people you surround yourself with."
Are you surrounding yourself with success?

Back
Top Bottom