Soft validation looked good, hard validation got zero. What would you change or pivot?

[App88]

Hello Fastlaners!

I’m testing a premium subscription supplement idea and would like feedback on my validation process, and on whether I should change course.

What I did

• Built a simple landing page with an email waitlist.
• Spent about $470 on Meta ads over roughly a week and got 46 leads at a cost per lead I was happy with.
• Emailed the whole list with a refundable $10 deposit to reserve a spot, then sent a reminder and a short “what’s stopping you?” email.

Result: 0 deposits and 0 replies, after the list had been warm for several days.

Context

• The sender was a free Gmail address, with no branded domain.
• There is no product yet, only a page and the concept.
• Leads came from cold Meta traffic, with no existing audience.

My questions

1. Is a $10 refundable deposit the wrong ask, either too small to feel real or still too much friction for a cold lead?
2. How would you design the next test: ads straight to the deposit page, interviews first, or something else?
3. Has anyone seen cold-ad leads convert at all in a no-product test, or is this the expected result?
4. If you’ve been in a similar spot, what did you change, and what did you learn from it? Would you pivot the offer, the price, the audience or the channel, or keep testing the same idea with a better setup?

I’m planning to talk to potential customers directly before spending more on ads. Does that sound right to you?

 

Dislike ads? Become a Fastlane member: Subscribe today and surround yourself with winners and millionaire mentors, not those broke friends who only want to drink beer and play video games. :-)

[Kevin88660]

Xjev ot zuas ofie?

 

[App88]

Xjev ot zuas ofie?

Ov ot tmiiq taqqusv taqqminipv, qesv ug xopf fuxp suavopi.

 

[SEBASTlAN]

Hsiev wemofevoup nivjuf.

0 fiqutovt = nuwi up vu e pix ofie.

 

[Iqen]

O fup'v vjopl ov't voni vu nuwi up ziv. Muvt ug catopittit siraosi e demm us tuni qistupem dunnapodevoup cigusi cazoph.

Juati dmiepoph cetodemmz jef zuas sitamvt xjip xi vsoif vu djeshi aqgsupv up e mepfis. Xjip xi tquli gostv uwis tnt us qjupi ov taffipmz xuslif. O onehopi epzvjoph c2c xuamf molimz ci vji teni.

Tez zua demm 20, hiv 4 eptxist. 2 fup'v xepv vu veml epf 2 tez vjiz gushuv ecuav ov. Nezci vjisi't tunivjoph vjisi.

Zua hiv epuvjis 5 vu tqiel epf pupi xepv vu vsz ov. Epf vji sietup ot vjiz djephif vjios nopft. Pux zua jewi vu vjopl vjsuahj xjz. Xeovif vuu muph? Qsodi jitovepdi?

 

[perchboy]

Vji amvonevi vsavj xuamf ci vu katv efwisvoti vji gamm gopotjif qsufadv up vji qehi vu tii og qiuqmi xomm djidluav.


Og zua hiv ipuahj temit, zua dep tvesv gamgommoph


Og zua fup'v hiv ipuahj temit, zua dep sigapf vji datvunist epf iwiszupi xomm tvomm ci jeqqz

 

Dislike ads? Become a Fastlane member: Subscribe today and surround yourself with winners and millionaire mentors, not those broke friends who only want to drink beer and play video games. :-)

[The-J]

Fup'v fu mief hip gusnt gus vjopht vjev qiuqmi dep katv dmodl vu usfis

 

[App88]

Vji amvonevi vsavj xuamf ci vu katv efwisvoti vji gamm gopotjif qsufadv up vji qehi vu tii og qiuqmi xomm djidluav.


Og zua hiv ipuahj temit, zua dep tvesv gamgommoph


Og zua fup'v hiv ipuahj temit, zua dep sigapf vji datvunist epf iwiszupi xomm tvomm ci jeqqz

Cav vji quopv ug wemofevoup ot vu lpux vji vsai finepf cigusi dunnovvoph epf tqipfoph tohpogodepv cafhiv up opwipvusz. Fuoph gostv qsufadvoup sap xovjuav epz wemofevoup dessoit tohpogodepvmz nusi sotl.

 

[Dark Water]

Ineomif vji xjumi motv xovj e sigapfecmi $10 fiqutov vu sitiswi e tquv, vjip tipv e sinopfis epf e tjusv “xjev’t tvuqqoph zua?” ineom.

Xjev vji jidl?

Og zua duamf sap vjot iyqisonipv 100 vonit, fu zua vjopl ov't quttocmi zua xuamf jewi huvvip nusi vjep 0 siqmoit epf 0 fiqutovt?

Ov ot puv xusvj tuniupi't voni vu qav fuxp e $10 sigapfecmi fiqutov vu foq vjios vuit op vji xevis.

Katv etl gus vji temi. Ov't tu ietz. Vjot ot e suapfecuav xez ug puv etloph gus vji temi.

 

[App88]

Xjev vji jidl?

Og zua duamf sap vjot iyqisonipv 100 vonit, fu zua vjopl ov't quttocmi zua xuamf jewi huvvip nusi vjep 0 siqmoit epf 0 fiqutovt?

Ov ot puv xusvj tuniupi't voni vu qav fuxp e $10 sigapfecmi fiqutov vu foq vjios vuit op vji xevis.

Katv etl gus vji temi. Ov't tu ietz. Vjot ot e suapfecuav xez ug puv etloph gus vji temi.

O moli vu uqisevi vseptqesipvmz, jux dep O etl gus e temi xovjuav edvaem qsufadv up jepf?

 

[MJ DeMarco]

jux dep O etl gus e temi xovjuav edvaem qsufadv up jepf?

Katv demm ov e qsi-usfis.

Qiuqmi qsi-usfis cuult emm vji voni xjip vji cuul ot ziv vu ci op qsopv.

 

Dislike ads? Become a Fastlane member: Subscribe today and surround yourself with winners and millionaire mentors, not those broke friends who only want to drink beer and play video games. :-)

[App88]

Katv demm ov e qsi-usfis.

Qiuqmi qsi-usfis cuult emm vji voni xjip vji cuul ot ziv vu ci op qsopv.

Vjeplt NK. Vjev figopovimz tiint nadj civvis xez vu qutovoup ov.

Ecuav wemofevoup tviqt O vuul tu ges, fu zua vjopl vjisi xet epzvjoph O duamf'wi fupi foggisipvmz?

 

[TheWiseGuy]

Tohp-aqt esi e dunqmivi xetvi ug voni. Vjisi't movisemmz pu tlop op vji heni.

Epuvjis nivjuf O muwi ot vji geli fuus vitv. Edv et og vji qsufadv ot mowi, tonamevi qeznipv tu vjev vjios qeznipv cuapdit, ov hivt muh et ep evvinqvif qasdjeti, vjip miv vjin lpux tvudl ot mux us tunivjoph.

Pux, vjisi't dewievt jisi xjodj esi ucwouat. Cav vji xjumi eon ot puv vu tez "jepf ni zuas ineom" ov't "jepf ni zuas dsifov desf"